American City and County

City manager takes pay cut to give other execs raises

It is a bid to keep top talent from leaving, he says

Here's something you don't see every day — a city manager who takes a pay cut so that two other city executives can get pay raises. That's what happened in San Leandro, Calif., according to The Daily Review, as city manager Chris Zapata took a $20,000 yearly pay cut to provide raises for the city's police chief and assistant city manager.

Zapata took the pay cut for two years to give $10,000 raises each year to the police chief and assistant city manager. "We have two extremely talented and marketable managers," Zapata told the City Council, according to the Daily Review. "They are vital to the management team."

Zapata said he feared that the police chief and assistant city manager would be lured away to other California cities, noting that there were vacancies for those jobs in San Jose, Fremont and Alameda. San Leandro has already experienced significant management turnover. Zapata is the city's fourth city manager since 2009 and both the community development manager and deputy city manager recently left for other jobs.

In return for the pay raises, the police chief and assistant city manager will commit to five-year contracts. Zapata's pay cut will cover the expenses for two years, with the money coming out of the general fund after that.

RELATED: City manager cuts his own job

The council approved Zapata's plan by a 5-2 vote. The dissenting council members said the management raises send the wrong message while the city is in contract talks with rank and file city workers.

Zapata's action, though unusual, is not unprecedented. In October, Peekskill, N.Y., acting city manager Brian Havranek proposed cutting his own job as part of a plan to help close the city's budget gap. And last March, Keller, Texas city manager Dan O'Leary, saying the city's administration was top-heavy, resigned so that his two assistant managers could keep their jobs.

Discuss this Article 1

Frank H. Rottinghaus
on Jan 7, 2013

This is an example of really bad governance by the City Council. It erodes the traditional relationship between the council and it's employees. What if the Manager is killed in an accident, God forbid.? Can he be replaced at a discounted salary level? This arrangement certainly affects the professional relationship between these 3 employees. Will the manager continue to do an effective job or will he not be concerned because he has done his part(foregone the compensation he was entitled to)? Just some questions that will yield answers that are not wanted by the public.

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your American City & County ID
(optional)

Get the latest information on government trends, policies, best practices and case studies.

Join American City and County on Twitter

Newsletter Signup

Used Equipment - Buy, Sell, Save!

Connect With Us